The USPTO refused registration of the mark
COOMI 47AG for "silver jewelry," absent a disclaimer of "47AG." Applicant appealed. Examining Attorney Patty Evanko maintained that "Ag" is the chemical symbol for silver and "47" is silver's atomic number, and so "47AG" describes the material composition of applicant's jewelry. Applicant argued that typical jewelry shoppers would not immediately recognize that meaning of "47AG." How do you think this came out?
In re Bhasin Enterprise Corporation, Serial No. 86025037 (January 2, 2015) [not precedential].
The Board pointed out that silver jewelry "is a consumer item of potentially universal appeal to individuals." The subject application contains no limitation as to the nature of the consumers, and so the Board must presume that they include "all normal customers for such goods, including individuals who have knowledge of the meaning of the terms 'Ag' and '47.'" Moreover, the Board has previously recognized the descriptive significance of chemical symbols (e.g., ZN-PLUS, MN-PLUS, and CA-PLUS). And the terms "Ag" and "47" are not jargon, but long-established and universally recognized scientific terms that may even be learned in high school. Thus many consumers, even those without a scientific background, would be aware of the terms.
There is nothing incongruous or unique about the combination of "47" and "AG." The evidence showed that they commonly appear together or in close proximity (see illustration above). The Board disagreed with applicant's argument that a multi-stage reasoning process would be required in order to derive an understanding of the term "47AG." When used together, "47" and "AG" merely reinforce each other in meaning.
The Board therefore found "47AG" to be merely descriptive of silver jewelry, and it affirmed the requirement of a disclaimer of the term. Applicant was allowed thirty days to submit the required disclaimer.
Read comments and post your comment hereTTABlog note: What is element 43? What is the atomic number of Kryptonite? Would "46AG" be half-descriptive?
Text Copyright John L. Welch 2015.
The drop in crude oil prices made me wonder if there would be any impact on the sale of Texas' largest ranch behind one fence: Waggoner Ranch.
After all, the oil business on the ranch has been one of the selling points of this piece of West Texas history that totals 510,527 acres and has about 1,000 working pump jacks.
"This ranch is part of one of the most unique stories in the country," said Dan Hunt, a real estate investor and a member of one of Texas' legendary oil families, in a previous interview.…
Best Buy Co. Inc. has introduced its own wedding registry, betting that modern couples are as interested in electronics and gadgets as they are in china and flatware.
The Associated Press reports on Best Buy Wedding Registry, which was introduced without much fanfare in January. Best Buy will introduce the service on its mobile app next week. Customers will be able to sync their Best Buy registries with third-party sites like TheKnot.com.
Best Buy (NYSE: BBY) is pitching the service to both men…
Robot domination may have just taken another step forward.
Just as venture capital investments in robotics are beginning to take off, the granddaddy of consumer robotics companies, iRobot, is launching a venture capital firm.