Saturday, January 24, 2015

TTAB Test: Must "47AG" Be Disclaimed for SiIver Jewelry?

The USPTO refused registration of the mark COOMI 47AG for "silver jewelry," absent a disclaimer of "47AG." Applicant appealed. Examining Attorney Patty Evanko maintained that "Ag" is the chemical symbol for silver and "47" is silver's atomic number, and so "47AG" describes the material composition of applicant's jewelry. Applicant argued that typical jewelry shoppers would not immediately recognize that meaning of "47AG." How do you think this came out? In re Bhasin Enterprise Corporation, Serial No. 86025037 (January 2, 2015) [not precedential].


The Board pointed out that silver jewelry "is a consumer item of potentially universal appeal to individuals." The subject application contains no limitation as to the nature of the consumers, and so the Board must presume that they include "all normal customers for such goods, including individuals who have knowledge of the meaning of the terms 'Ag' and '47.'" Moreover, the Board has previously recognized the descriptive significance of chemical symbols (e.g., ZN-PLUS, MN-PLUS, and CA-PLUS). And the terms "Ag" and "47" are not jargon, but long-established and universally recognized scientific terms that may even be learned in high school. Thus many consumers, even those without a scientific background, would be aware of the terms.

There is nothing incongruous or unique about the combination of "47" and "AG." The evidence showed that they commonly appear together or in close proximity (see illustration above). The Board disagreed with applicant's argument that a multi-stage reasoning process would be required in order to derive an understanding of the term "47AG." When used together, "47" and "AG" merely reinforce each other in meaning.

The Board therefore found "47AG" to be merely descriptive of silver jewelry, and it affirmed the requirement of a disclaimer of the term. Applicant was allowed thirty days to submit the required disclaimer.

Read comments and post your comment here

TTABlog note: What is element 43? What is the atomic number of Kryptonite? Would "46AG" be half-descriptive?

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2015.

$40M waterfront restaurant, retail venue at Kewalo Basin to start construction in September

A Japanese partnership is planning to start construction in September on a $40 million multi-use facility at Kewalo Basin in Honolulu that would include waterfront retail, restaurants and a live entertainment venue. Kewalo Waterfront Partners Inc., which was formed by Japan-based Good Luck International Corp., and fellow Japan firm Hinamari Hawaii Inc., said in a draft environmental assessment that the project is anticipated to be completed by December 2016. The entity also said that it will provide…

Friday, January 23, 2015

The Dawn Of Our Robot Overlords Inches Closer As iRobot Starts VC Shop

11344262713_f4eb7c211e_o Robot domination may have just taken another step forward. Just as venture capital investments in robotics are beginning to take off, the granddaddy of consumer robotics companies, iRobot, is launching a venture capital firm. Read More

YC-Backed Bluesmart Raises $2 Million For Its Self-Tracking Suitcase

screen-shot-2014-11-17-at-10-10-03-am “Imagine a world where you never lose your luggage,” says CEO of Bluesmart, Diego Saez-Gil. He motions to a compact carry-on suitcase sitting beside us and tells me he can track this piece of luggage anywhere. Saez-Gil’s Y Combinator-backed startup makes these hardshell suitcases. It can locate, lock and weigh your belongings from an app on your smartphone. Read More

Kredo Helps You Make Your Portfolio Fancy

IMG_2896 You may be fancy and everybody already knows this, but does your portfolio reflect that? Kredo, a new portfolio app, will help you and those around you find out just how fancy you are. Created by Lukas Dryja and Tyler Rooney, Kredo was built after the pair realized their artist friends had no online portfolios. A good, custom website cost money so they decided to bootstrap a cheap solution. It… Read More

TTAB Test: Must "47 AG" Be Disclaimed for SiIver Jewelry?

The USPTO refused registration of the mark COOMI 47AG for "silver jewelry," absent a disclaimer of "47AG." Applicant appealed. Examining Attorney Patty Evanko maintained that "Ag" is the chemical symbol for silver and "47" is silver's atomic number, and so "47AG" describes the material composition of applicant's jewelry. Applicant argued that typical jewelry shoppers would not immediately recognize that meaning of "47AG." How do you think this came out? In re Bhasin Enterprise Corporation, Serial No. 86025037 (January 2, 2015) [not precedential].


The Board pointed out that silver jewelry "is a consumer item of potentially universal appeal to individuals." The subject application contains no limitation as to the nature of the consumers, and so the Board must presume that they include "all normal customers for such goods, including individuals who have knowledge of the meaning of the terms 'Ag' and '47.'" Moreover, the Board has previously recognized the descriptive significance of chemical symbols (e.g., ZN-PLUS, MN-PLUS, and CA-PLUS). And the terms "Ag" and "47" are not jargon, but long-established and universally recognized scientific terms that may even be learned in high school. Thus many consumers, even those without a scientific background, would be aware of the terms.

There is nothing incongruous or unique about the combination of "47" and "AG." The evidence showed that they commonly appear together or in close proximity (see illustration above). The Board disagreed with applicant's argument that a multi-stage reasoning process would be required in order to derive an understanding of the term "47AG." When used together, "47" and "AG" merely reinforce each other in meaning.

The Board therefore found "47AG" to be merely descriptive of silver jewelry, and it affirmed the requirement of a disclaimer of the term. Applicant was allowed thirty days to submit the required disclaimer.

Read comments and post your comment here

TTABlog note: What is element 43? What is the atomic number of Kryptonite? Would "46AG" be half-descriptive?

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2015.

Scottsdale promoter: Relationships key to a successful Super Bowl event

The key to a good party is relationships. That's what local events promoter Steve LeVine is finding out as he prepares for hosting and promoting events around the upcoming Super Bowl. LeVine said his firm, Steve LeVine Entertainment & Public Relations, has been involved with more than 45 events in the two weeks leading up to Super Bowl XLIX. He said he was able to land a majority of those clients because of pre-existing relationships. "Last Super Bowl we started to make a name for ourselves and…